Discover this place
Nestled in the heart of Krebs, Oklahoma, Isle of Capri stands out as a hidden gem in the Italian dining scene. The reviews from patrons sing praises of its delectable offerings, particularly the chateaubriand family dinner, hailed by Shelby Hill Tatarian as one of the best steaks she's ever tasted. The rich and flavorful spaghetti, a staple in Italian cuisine, has also garnered admiration, proving to be a crowd favorite. Customers like Kyle Foster affirm that the quality of food at Isle of Capri is unmatched, complemented by exceptional service that makes every dining experience memorable. Indo Singa echoes this sentiment, emphasizing the restaurant's commitment to high-quality ingredients, especially in their steak, which leaves diners craving more. The ambiance strikes a perfect balance between warmth and elegance, as noted by Jordan Gibson, who felt as though he had stumbled into a high-class establishment. This sense of family extends beyond the meal, with friendly staff treating guests like relatives, as noted by Carlos Montoya. With fresh ingredients like their homemade bread and lively atmospheres, Isle of Capri demonstrates that high-quality Italian cuisine can indeed thrive in Oklahoma. A visit here not only satisfies one's palate but also leaves an enduring impression of hospitality and comfort.Photos
Amenities & More
Service options
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Dining options
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Seating
Reviews for Isle of Capri
Review highlights
Based on 188 reviewsIsle of Capri in Krebs, Oklahoma, garners consistent praise for its authentic Italian cuisine, with particular emphasis on high-quality steaks, pasta, and freshly prepared bread. Reviewers frequently highlight the restaurant’s warm, family-run atmosphere and attentive service, contributing to a welcoming and upscale dining experience. The combination of flavorful, well-executed dishes and genuine hospitality positions Isle of Capri as a standout choice for Italian food in the region. Patrons appreciate both the taste and the ambiance, often noting the owners’ personal involvement and the staff’s friendly demeanor, which together elevate the overall experience beyond typical local dining options.
On the recommendation of a friend who grew up in the area, we had the chateaubriand family dinner - so incredible. One of the best steaks of my life, amazing spaghetti, just all-around deliciousness.
Oklahoma's best Italian food, hands down. Excellent service and the food quality can't be beat.
All the foods that I ate was so delicious, especially the steak with high quality of the meat it’s so yummy and perfect !
The food and the atmosphere was phenomenal. Truly felt like a high class dining experience. The owners family runs the place and could not be more kind or accommodating. Being a lifelong resident of the Mcalester and Krebs area I can confidently say that I will choose the Isle every chance I get
The spaghetti and fresh buttered bread were delicious! The salad was fresh too. I have to say this place shocked me, as I never thought I'd find an authentic Italian restaurant in Oklahoma. The staff was very friendly and treated us like family. The owner was super nice!
Excellent food and service. Family style dining with so much food you would think it was a holiday dinner at Grandmas house. Staff was friendly and attentive with out being intrusive. Elegant but comfortable dining. I am a return customer that has never left discontent or without a doggie bag. :)
I ate here tonight with two of my buddies, we had such a great experience. The owner, Stephanie, said she learned all of the recipes from her father. Every dish we had was amazing and we will most definitely be coming back! This is a must stop if you are in town, family-friendly and what a wonderful owner.
When we were there someone had rented the place for a special family event and they included us. We got to try everything and only left a big tip and with warm memories.
Write a review
Share your experience with the community. Your honest feedback helps others find great places.
Quick info
Location
Own this business?
Claim this listing to update info, respond to reviews and reach more customers.
Claim listingMore places in Oklahoma
Discover more places like this
Browse thousands of bars, restaurants, cafés and more — wherever you go.